Louisiana’s Student’s Rights Review Receives Mix Reviews

On January 2, 2018, Louisiana Attorney General Jeff Landry and U.S. Rep. Mike Johnson released guidelines about religion in public schools, called the Louisiana Student Rights Review, which includes answers to 26 “frequently asked questions” about religious freedom and public school education.

Its opening page states:

The right to religious expression, in particular, has been increasingly challenged and misunderstood in recent years, and many people have been led to believe our elementary and secondary schools must be “religion-free” zones. To the contrary, both federal and state laws specifically protect religious freedom rights in public schools. Thankfully, Congress and our state legislature still recognize the fundamental importance of religious liberty—the first freedom listed in the Constitution’s Bill of Rights.

This Louisiana Student Rights Review answers some of the most frequently asked questions and misconceptions about the law in this area. Our hope is that this publication will be: a helpful resource for Louisiana students, parents, teachers, coaches, administrators and school board members; a tool in avoiding campus controversies; and a positive reminder that when the government acknowledges “[w]e are a religious people whose institutions presuppose a Supreme Being… it follows the best of our traditions.”

The document is published and copyrighted by the Louisiana Department of Justice, and is divided into three section using a question-and-answer format. These sections address a student’s right to express religious beliefs, a student group’s right to express religious beliefs, and the rights of school employees to express their religious beliefs.

The 15-page publication was mailed to all school superintendents in Louisiana and is available for free online.

It has received both criticism and acclaim.

Mixed reviews came from representatives of the ACLU of Louisiana and the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) who told the Shreveport Times that most of the law cited in the document is accurate– however, they have filed complaints or lawsuits in parishes specifically about religious expression in public schools. The ACLU also posted online its joint statement on religion in public schools.

LSU law professor John Devlin remarked that the report “describes current law with care,” “is well-sourced,” and “provides clarity on fundamental points” like school authorities “not sponsoring or promoting particular forms of religious expression.”

Representatives from the ACLU of Louisiana and FFRF and Devlin identified problems with it, arguing that it focuses too much on Christianity and in some ways could even be construed as promoting it.

Mat Staver, the founder of Liberty Counsel, which represents Child Evangelism Fellowship nationally, commended the report. He said, “Students may exercise their constitutional rights to religious free speech while on public school campuses during non-instructional times. They do not give up those rights just because they are in a public school.”

The issue of offering guidelines about religion in Louisiana public schools is not new. In 2009, members of the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education unanimously voted to adopt new rules that eliminated language that would have banned the teaching of “creationism or intelligent design” and teaching materials that “advance the religious belief that a supernatural being created humankind.”

This, along with other efforts in 2011, followed the 1982 “balanced treatment” law, which required schools to teach both “creation science” and evolution but was struck down by the Supreme Court in 1987. And last spring, the University of Louisiana at Lafayette clarified legal questions related to prayer in public school at its annual legal conference.

The Attorney General’s report is the most recent guideline in a history of the state’s efforts to ensure the limits of constitutionally-protected freedoms are made clear.



Interested in more national news? We've got you covered! See More National News
Previous Article
Next Article
Join the Conversation - Download the Speakeasy App.

Trending on The Hayride