MIKE CHECK: The Media’s Uncreative Case Against Lane Kiffin

We are very late with this week’s edition of Mike Check, and for those following the series, we apologize.

When the same carbon-copy contempt comes at us through enough television shows, headlines, podcasts, and social media clips, if we’re not aware of what is going on, it all begins to feel like a conclusion everybody reached independently—and therefore must be true. It’s the rule of the mob, mentioned in a famous line spoken by Gracchus in the movie Gladiator, illustrated so poignantly when the mob chose Barabbas over Christ 2000 years ago. “Strength in numbers” is more than just a cliche; people feel safer inside a tribe than they do speaking out against it. There is comfort there, even if a part of them believes they are following something unfair or even untrue.

Before long in a mob-run society like our own, a football coach’s potential weaknesses and failures—those not created by said mob, mind you—have become an invitation to participate in his public humiliation, with each new voice making the temptation to pile on harder to resist.

The whole time, we could be wrong.

And even if we are right in most ways, what we don’t know is that we are not called to be the arbiters of justice in every single media-driven story in our lives.

That consolidation of hostility—aimed at Coach Lane Kiffin—is the topic of this Mike Check. Over the years, Kiffin has given the media plenty to criticize, and this space has been selective in choosing which of those topics to address. But the overall coverage of the man increasingly asks of fans something far beyond a simple evaluation of LSU’s football program. It seems to me, in all its emotion and vitriol, to be encouraging the audience to enjoy the destruction of the man running it.

Lest we forget—or in case we’ve never been told:

  1. “When thy enemy shall fall, be not glad, and in his ruin let not thy heart rejoice: Lest the Lord see, and it displease him, and he turn away his wrath from him.” – Proverbs 24:17–18, Douay-Rheims.
  2. “He that despiseth the poor, reproacheth his Maker; and he that rejoiceth at another man’s ruin, shall not be unpunished.” – Proverbs 17:5, Douay-Rheims.
  3. “But thou shalt not look on in the day of thy brother, in the day of his leaving his country: and thou shalt not rejoice over the children of Juda, in the day of their destruction: and thou shalt not magnify thy mouth in the day of distress.”
    — Abdias 1:12, Douay-Rheims
  4. “Let them not say in their hearts: It is well, it is well, to our mind: neither let them say: We have swallowed him up. Let them blush: and be ashamed together, who rejoice at my evils.” – Psalm 34:25–26, Douay-Rheims; Divine Office, Roman Breviary (1939), Tuesday Matins, First Nocturn, third psalm section.

I pray the 1939 and/or 1962 versions of the Divine Office every day. This is a central theme in the prayers. Yes, punishment may come to someone through humiliation, but that doesn’t excuse the malice of those through whom it comes.

In his November 19 column, “How about lowering the heat on Lane Kiffin?,” Ron Higgins identifies one aspect behind this whole ongoing attack: ESPN’s numerous platforms allow Paul Finebaum to deliver his judgment repeatedly across different programs. Following LSU’s loss to Texas, that judgment included calling Kiffin “a broken man” who had “thrown up all over himself.”

Finebaum may have legitimate criticisms of Kiffin. But do you really want to go the way of Babylon in agreeing with him?

Finebaum’s made-for-sound-bite phrases tell us much more about Finebaum and the media than they tell us new about Lane Kiffin or the sport of college football. But true “news” doesn’t matter to these people. Once the spectacle of it all becomes a humiliation worth replaying over and over again, the network can keep selling the same emotional response through another show, another panel, another clip. Multiply that times millions and millions of user accounts, likes, and shares, and you have a mob assault we should wish on no one.

Whether particular voices are following corporate direction, copying one another, or securing the same promised incentives through their commentary, the resulting mimetic energy can sweep a nation toward a hostility far stronger than the underlying fallenness of a man warrants.

Although many will dismiss any connection between sports coverage and the broader media wickedness so many have come to recognize since 2020, I find the resemblance difficult to ignore. We all recognize the effect when celebrity voices coalesce for a cause or when the day’s talking points sound stunningly similar across supposedly independent sources. It’s called flooding the zone. So whether it makes any sense or not for Lane Kiffin and LSU football to be related to, let’s say, a Donald Trump-Elon Musk squabble from 2025, we should be quick to realize that the powers that be are about the business of relentlessly presenting to us the illusion of choice.

The point? Because they want to be able to sway the mob, and if they do it in seemingly trivial areas in the same way they do it in seemingly pivotal areas, it is more likely to become a habit-character-destiny reality. It already has become that, which returns me to the reason so many would dismiss my claim here. A relatively small subject like Lane Kiffin can still provide practice in a larger habit, which creates character, which creates destiny—a reality completely severed from God.

While we won’t be addressing the story specifically here, the same concern extends to the controversy surrounding LSU basketball player RJ Luis, regardless of where you fall on that issue.

The point isn’t the issue—that’s what people don’t understand. It’s drumming up a certain sentiment toward that issue that is important.

Advertisement

This space objects to such excess while still recognizing the value in honest evaluation. That brings us to this week’s game in Knoxville….

For three weeks now, our basic evaluation has remained unchanged. LSU needed to show that its schematic choices, quarterback decisions, and fourth-quarter execution could withstand top-10 competition. All this “improvement” talk from the last coaching staff to this one needed such tangible results. Alabama and Texas were two prime opportunities inside Tiger Stadium, and Kiffin went 0-2, worsening his already-abysmal career record against top-10 teams. His final regular-season opportunity now comes against No. 9 Tennessee—and in the considerably less accommodating environment of Rocky Top.

Contrary to all three Tiger Rag predictions, we are picking the Volunteers here because the corrections that would warrant picking our Tigers simply aren’t there. Among a litany of other mind-boggling stats we don’t need to regurgitate here, LSU went a combined 4-for-9 in the redzone against Alabama and Texas, was outscored 23-0 in those fourth quarters, and watched Sam Leavitt throw three interceptions against the Longhorns. Tennessee’s defense, with its 39 sacks and 19 takeaways, presents another serious test of an offense that can look like the best in the nation before it reaches the 20-yard line.

We’ll say it again: The rule, the discipline, the order—they all must come before the extras. Perhaps being on the road the final two games of the year will finally help make that happen.

But we’re not putting any money on it.

In my eyes, LSU must beat Tennessee and then lowly Arkansas to finish 8-4 for this season to avoid being an unexpected failure—a failure many a talking head out there is already claiming. Given where the Tigers were to end last season, and given the fact that they are not the only team shelling out such millions to make the playoffs, I believe they should have won every game they lost, with the possible exception of Ole Miss. That is not an earth-shattering opinion no one else shares, admittedly. Still, when measured against reasonable preseason expectations for a first-year coach in this position, an 8-4 finish in this case provides reason to look forward to 2027 with cautious optimism that this program can indeed finish games. The close losses would then morph from abject failures to tangible progress.

As even Kiffin so often says, and as the thesis of this very piece first argued, it’s all in the narrative people hear. Winning in Knoxville is a demanding ask to “save” Kiffin’s first season, but without it, the narrative has nothing to take root in.

And any virtue the Finebaums of the world might suddenly discover will vanish in the face of those who provide the marching orders.

Kiffin is not a humble man, no. Kiffin owes LSU better redzone play and more victories, yes. But alongside that, and even more importantly for their own sake, the media owe their audiences better than another uncreative invitation to hate him.

Thank you for reading The Hayride!

Advertisement

Advertisement

Interested in more news from Louisiana? We've got you covered! See More Louisiana News
Previous Article

Trending on The Hayride