Both Caddoans and Bossierites have a chance to recover from a mistake they made a dozen years ago by turning down supposedly only taxing somebody behind a tree for unnecessary causes.
On Dec. 12, voters in both parishes will be asked to continue a 1.5 percent tax on hotel room, motel room, and camping site rentals, scheduled to expire next Jun. 30. The Shreveport-Bossier Convention and Tourist Bureau’s Shreveport-Bossier Sports Commission, the Independence Bowl, and essentially Shreveport Regional Airport all get a 0.5 percent cut from it, estimated to be just under $1.8 million annually, for the next 12 years after expiration.
Pass through organizations – the Commission, the Independence Bowl Foundation, and the Ark-La-Tex Regional Service Alliance which works with the city-owned airport – would receive the money. The larger Bureau also receives a much bigger slice of occupancy taxes from another source. Last year, both the Foundation and Alliance reported their shares as over $800,000.
Not that the Commission nor Alliance needs it. The latter, which uses around that sum to attract carriers, sits on about $5 million in reserves with minimal expenses. It would make far more sense for the city to pay such bribery to airlines rather than this circuitous route, but its going to be strapped for decades to come. In any event, the money in reserves could pay the enticement for at least six more years, by which time a critical mass should be established if not already, evidenced by continued airline willingness to add flights.
As for the former, it’s awash in cash at around $11 million in reserve and already receives the bulk of its funding from occupancy taxation, banking more every year. It would be hard to argue the marginal gains from an extra few hundred thousands of dollars paid out to suck in sporting events ever pay back in tax receipts from any such ones attracted.
Especially when the big one is the Independence Bowl game. Of the three entities, the Foundation has the best case for taxpayer dollars, as it has only around $2 million in cash reserves and certainly has seen its financial situation become more stable because of the tax. Even so, last year it made just about enough to cover the collections and gets government handouts annually, but also voters should ponder whether they should be on the hook for a private organization running a football game, the economic impact of which is unlikely to compensate for the money taken out of pocketbooks.
But, backers of the tax in recycling a tired argument maintain, taken out of somebody else’s pocketbook. As it is an occupancy tax, they say, nonresidents pay. That’s not quite true and dodges economic truths. Sometimes residents do end up having to stay in area lodging facilities and end up paying directly or indirectly. Yet of more concern, higher prices, even if only a dollar or two more per night, at the margins discourage consumption, lowering purveyors’ profits and therefore has negative ripples throughout the local economy as the capacity is there for the same functions to continue without need of subsidy.
Bossier voters particularly should be sensitized to this tax. They likely disproportionately suffer from the marginal slowdown in economic activity as compared to having the activities of the three organizations continue without the tax. On balance those activities, with the game on Shreveport’s field, travel through Shreveport’s airport, and Shreveport’s greater venue choices for sports (although Bossier City’s Brookshires Grocery Arena can hold its own) means the increased tax derived from the subsidized activities mostly benefits businesses located in Shreveport.
Perhaps for that reason, Bossier voters basically defeated a first iteration of the tax for 2014, but a slightly smaller version passed muster a year later. In 2026, voters on both sides of the river should reject its renewal.
Advertisement
Advertisement