MASSON: Saints head-coaching job much more desirable than two years ago

NFL football is a zero sum game. That means for every win, there is a loss. The collective record of all NFL teams at the end of the regular season is 272-272.

So successful coaches at the NFL level don’t only have to be great coaches — they have to be better than 16 other coaches in order to have a winning season. That’s a small pool of elite-level talent.

Between the 2024 and 2025 seasons, the New Orleans Saints were competing with six other teams to fill head-coaching vacancies. With a roster in utter disarray and the team in salary-cap hell, thanks to mismanagement by the villainous Mickey Loomis, the Saints weren’t exactly a prime landing zone. None of the most sought-after candidates wanted anything to do with the train wreck on Airline Drive.

Some, like Aaron Glenn, were polite and interviewed for the position before taking better offers. Others, like Kliff Kingsbury, said it’s probably best to not waste everyone’s time. Kingsbury kept an offensive coordinator job rather than agreeing to even be interviewed for New Orleans’ head-coaching position.

That’s how much nobody wanted the Saints job.

So like a chronic snacker who reaches for a three-year-old frost-burnt dried-out popsicle at the back of the freezer, the Saints settled for Kellen Moore, a 36-year-old Washington native who somehow helped guide the Philadelphia Eagles to a Super Bowl win the previous season.

The first half of Moore’s debut season as Saints coach went about as well as expected, with the team dropping seven of its first eight games. To stanch the bleeding, Moore replaced second-year QB Spencer Rattler with rookie second-round choice Tyler Shough, and the team’s fortunes seemed to immediately improve. The Saints won five of their final nine games, and during the offseason, the Saints became a trendy pick to win the NFC South in 2026.

Fans can be forgiven for thinking maybe the team had caught lightning in a bottle with the Moore hiring.

Then the 2026 season actually arrived, and seven games in, fans would like to see Moore strapped to a SpaceX rocket and propelled directly toward the sun.

Every week, the team is ill-prepared, most clearly indicated by an absurd amount of pre-snap penalties, including illegal shifts and illegal formations. Its only consistencies are that it will be entirely incapable of running the ball and will score few if any points until its back is against the wall and it has to chuck the game plan and play street football.

In post-game interviews, players are sending signals that Moore is a complete disaster, and that is evident in the product on the field.

Moore seems like a loyal guy, which in some fields is an admirable quality. But in the NFL, it’s a fast-track to the unemployment line. Saints kicker Daniel “Tucker” Carlson has missed a kick in every game so far this year, and yet, Moore refuses to move on from him. Little Blake Grupe with a torn ACL would be an upgrade.

Even worse, offensive line coach Brendan Nugent has overseen a unit that has regressed substantially from the halcyon days of Dennis Allen’s tenure, and can’t open holes for running backs or adequately protect Shough. Has he been given his walking papers? Of course not. Moore must be thinking there’s no possible way he can get any worse, so we might as well keep him.

The Saints sit at 2-5 heading into the bye, and it’s become a foregone conclusion that Moore will be looking for work in 2027. He might as well put his house up for sale now so he has time to move it in this weak real estate market.

The only question is when precisely Moore will be given his walking papers, and whether Loomis helps pack up his office, or if Loomis himself has to box up everything he’s acquired during his quarter-century tenure with the organization.

Things would have to really go to hell for Moore to get fired midseason. There’s really no advantage to it, and it sends the signal that the organization has an itchy trigger finger and won’t give a young coach the time he needs to patch up a sinking ship.

So more than likely, Moore will survive until Black Monday.

Whether Loomis is around to make the next hire or not, the Saints job will be much more desirable than it was in 2025, and that’s because the incoming coach will have the most important element for success already in the building.

In the right program, Tyler Shough will be a top 5 NFL quarterback. Look what he’s doing with absolutely no running game, an offensive line in disarray and the worst Saints head coach since Mike Ditka, may he rest in peace.

Shough can still be thought of as a rookie, since he has yet to play a complete NFL season, and already he ranks ninth in passing yards (1,721), seventh in touchdowns (13) and has a 90.9 passer rating with a 13:6 touchdown-to-interception ratio.

Just think what somebody like Sean Payton in his prime could do with Shough. He may not be Drew Brees 2.0, but he’s got the skills and leadership ability to carry this franchise deep into the playoffs.

Shough is also playing under his rookie contract, which frees up money for the team to invest in other, much-needed areas.

You’ve got to think some wunderkind like Grant Udinski or Declan Doyle would salivate over the thought of getting to work with Shough.

Even better, the Saints have a top-5 wide receiver in Chris Olave and another with the athleticism to reach that level if he can, like Christian Watson, figure out his hamstring issues. Also, the offensive line has the horsepower to be better than average and maybe even good if the team could get the right coach in place.

The defense has a strong secondary, one good linebacker and one great defensive end, so there are definitely some holes to fill there, but no coaching job opens up for a good team. The Saints will likely have the most desirable situation of the bunch.

Team management has GOT to do a better job than it did in 2025, and with Shough locked down for another couple years, it won’t likely have any coaches say thanks, but no thanks.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Interested in more news from Louisiana? We've got you covered! See More Louisiana News
Previous Article
Next Article

Trending on The Hayride